Monday, June 7, 2010

Total Eclipse

Sumeet,
So this essay to me was completely confusing. I did not enjoy as I enjoyed the others. I believe it was to long for my taste. I think the theme and the hidden message in this essay is about how we don't fully appreciate things, and we kind of know about them but we simply just don't really care. We are fine the way we are and we don't need to improve or see more. Yet I found it odd how Dillard expresses fear towards the eclipse. I always thought that Dillard like the unknown and kind of nature miracles but through this essay she discuses the fear she has towards the eclipse and “it had been like dying, that sliding down the mountain pass,” (page 84). I mean she even starts off the essay with how terrified she was of the eclipse and foreshadows the rest of the essay. So my kind of question for you is first of all if you disagree with my point of view (which you probably will) and what you think about Dillard's scare of the unknown, darkness?

3 comments:

  1. Daniella,
    Yes, you are right, this essay was long, which caused me not to enjoy it as much as the others, but I still appreciated Dillard’s ideas and thoughts. You are wrong, I do not disagree with you, actually, I completely agree with you. I feel that the main point in the essay was the way us humans, in this case the speaker, do not fully realize the importance of certain things in life. The fact that the speaker felt fear when observing the eclipse just confuses me, and just makes me think how some people don’t value and cherish the opportunities they have in life. For example, towards the end of the essay, Dillard writes: “a sight rare enough, and one which, in itself, we would probably have driven five hours to see. But enough is enough.” In this example, we can evidently see the lack of interest and consideration from the speaker, who simply does not appreciate the eclipse, a one in a life time moment. I feel that Dillard’s scare of the unknown darkness comes from the deep and personal side of her. It is not possible that a person rejects a moment like an eclipse, and therefore, I believe that her scare of the unknown darkness had to be because of personal motives. Daniella, getting more personal, how would you have reacted if you were to be in the same position as Dillard? Why?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sumeet,
    I am shocked you agree with me but I'm glad you see what I saw in the essay. I believe that if I were in her situation I would be scared as well yet I would still want to see it as well. A whole minute of darkness in the earth is pretty awesome. But going back into the essay in the begging it talks about a clown made out of vegetables. And I don't know why Dillard would describe the painting in her essay. Like did Dillard describe the freaky clown painting for a reason or is it just there to make the essay more detailed in what they saw. What do you think? Also I thought the miners which she describes in the essay as well have a purpose and important role yet I have no idea what. She describes the miners being in the same situation as she is in a way. Like when she says "when the miners return to the surface, their faces are deadly pale" which after her watching the eclipse she was deadly terrified. I believe Dillard put the miners for a deeper reason yet I do not know exactly why. Do you?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Daniella,
    I am shocked that you are shocked with the fact that I agree with you. Anyways, I feel that at the beginning of the essay, when Dillard describes the clown, the reader gets a clear image of the intimidating and frightening ways a clown can be. I feel that this is a foreshadowing attempt by the author, who explains that by the same reason some people are afraid of clowns, why can’t someone be afraid of eclipses. If I am right, I feel that this is an exaggeration by her part, as clown and eclipses are completely different things; however, her argument is acceptable. About the miners, I feel that Dillard attempts to express how, just like the miners look for gold, she looks for the sun. I, like you, am not sure, but this is a connection I can make.

    ReplyDelete