Daniella,
As I read the essay "In the Jungle" by Annie Dillard, many thoughts came to my head. In this essay, Dillard shows the importance of life, something which truly stood out to me, and made me think about how most human beings are stuck in their own little world. Most of us have not been “living” because we have not appreciated the wonders in our planet. This made me think of some questions such as: How do you feel Dillard expresses the meaning of life through the enriching imagery she incorporates? In what ways has Dillard brought the essay to life?
Sumeet,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that the vivid imagery helped to transport one to the jungle. As I was there last I could really connect and understand with what Dillard says. The jungle is such a soothing and amazing place it makes you never want to leave. I felt that through the use of personification and similes she was able to bring the jungle to life. For example, when she says "Each breath of night smelled sweet"(54) it helped me to really sense the night. Another example of how a simile brings the jungle alive is "The lake and river-waters are as opaque as rain-forest leaves; they are veils, blinds, painted screens."(58) Now in regards to the meaning of life I'm not sure I agree with you that we haven't lived because we don't appreciate our planet; however, it definitely adds flavor to our lives.
This is an exciting argument between the two of you and I want you to explore and defend your positions.
ReplyDeleteSumeet, you propose we aren't living because we don't appreciate the planet. And in some respects it seems that Dillard would agree. How so? Where and why?
Yet Daniella, I think you are alluding to the opposite. Just because we don't appreciate the jungle and our planet doesn't mean we haven't lived. How does Dillard also support this idea?
I would like to see some intellectual bantering going on.
Daniella,
ReplyDeleteNow that you express your disagreement, I want to restate my prior statement about life by saying that we humans have not been living our lives to the fullest, meaning that we still have more to experience and go through in our lives. I am sure that after you went to the jungle, you were able to understand and perceive what Dillard wants to express. I, as a person who has also gone to the jungle, have experienced the wonders the jungle offers, and it is then when I realized that I was being a witness of the “real” world. It gave me another perspective about life, and that is why I believe that this place must be the reason why we humans live for. At the beginning of the essay, Dillard supports my argument by saying: “Out of the way of human life, tenderness, or the glance of heaven?”. The author even makes reference to heaven in this occasion, making the reader and I believe that the jungle is truly a unique, distinctive, and exceptional place one must visit. Once again, I finish by saying that we humans don’t appreciate what we have around us, and it is now the time for us to start treasuring our surroundings.
English Teacher: Dillard supports the idea of adding flavor to our lives when she says "what is there is interesting" (page 55). Here Dillard is agreeing with my argument of life becoming more exiting when you actually get to see what is here in our planet, yet their are other things such as growing up, becoming parents that enrich our lives and turn it real. Another example of this is when Dillard says "The Napo river: it is not out of the way. It is in the way" "catching" "peace" (page 59). I think what Dillard is trying to transmit is that the jungle can be a place where we find meaning and peace.
ReplyDeleteSumeet,
I agree with you about the jungle being heaven not only for Dillard but for all of us. The way Dillard quotes this idea with the use of a metaphor "the glance of heaven" (page 53) adds the passion that she has for the jungle. However, when you argue that we still have more to experience and go through in our lives doesn't that include other things then just looking at the jungle? I mean experience is all around us not just in the jungle. I think Dillard agrees with this statement when she says "what is there is interesting" (page 55) I believe that what Dillard is trying to express is that the jungle like any other place in the planet provides experiences to us worth getting to know. Moreover, I think that she also proves that the jungle is just one place of experience when she says "not to see the most spectacular anything. It is simply to see what is there." (page 55). This quote shows how the jungle is just another experience in the many we still have to live. Even thought the jungle is heaven to her she still realizes that there are other things out there.
Daniella,
ReplyDeleteI see where you are going with your argument, and you support it very well, but I still have to keep my opinion. Your examples might be proving me wrong, but I have more of Dillard’s examples to help my argument. For instance, Dillard writes: “It makes me wonder why I’m going back.” This clearly shows the author’s deep and meaningful connection with the jungle, which evidently is something which has impacted her throughout her life. Humans must realize that it is the natural surroundings the planet provides that has lead us on being the people we are today and will bring us all together in times of crisis. The jungle is the place where nature can be witnessed at its maximum, and that is what the author wants to transmit. Moreover, Dillard continues to value the jungle, and even compares it to be like home. For instance, the author writes: “This will do, I thought. This will do, for a weekend, or a season, or a home.” Here the reader can appreciate Dillard’s desire for more and the build up she creates. In this case, Dillard shows that she is not satisfied for staying for neither a weekend nor a season, but staying forever is what she wants. Once again, Dillard supports my argument in ways that prove how we don’t appreciate the planet we live in.