Daniella,
As I read “A Field of Silence”, I immediately became confused about the point Dillard wanted to express. However, throughout the essay, I could feel the silence she wanted to transmit to the reader, and she manages this by effectively incorporating literary devices such as similes and imagery. For example she writes: “There was only silence. It was the silence of matter caught in the act and embarrassed. There were no cells moving, and yet there were cells. I could see the shape of the land, how it lay holding silence”. I, personally, really connected with this as I could actually feel, witness, and pretend I was surrounded by silence. It was a special sensation I received as if all my troubles were behind me and I had nothing to worry about. At the beginning, I feel Dillard is telling a story, but towards the end she adds her own personal view about the experience she went through. Daniella, how do you feel about Dillard’s way of expressing silence? What do you think is the theme of this essay? How and in what ways may religion be considered a theme in this essay?
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
Lenses
Daniella,
I feel that the essay “Lenses” has a theme that expresses the importance and significance of the human senses. I feel that the essay is oddly separated into two different stories, but deals with the same theme all throughout. For the first story, which was about the speaker’s microscope and the specific details it provides, I feel that Dillard makes a clear point about our senses, especially our sight. For example, she writes: “You watch these swaying yellow, green, and brown strands of algae half mesmerized; you sink into the microscope’s field forgetful, oblivious, as if it were all a dream of your deepest brain.” I feel that Dillard highlights the importance of our senses, as they allow us to recognize the diverse and different properties the earth provides. For the second story, which was about the descriptions of swans, Dillard specifically describes details of what she senses. For example she writes: “when they emerged they were flying suddenly very high, and it was like music changing key.” Here, Dillard incorporates two senses, which are hearing and seeing. Daniella, why do you think Dillard changes the subject after telling her story about her microscope by saying, “But oddly, this story is about swans.”?
I feel that the essay “Lenses” has a theme that expresses the importance and significance of the human senses. I feel that the essay is oddly separated into two different stories, but deals with the same theme all throughout. For the first story, which was about the speaker’s microscope and the specific details it provides, I feel that Dillard makes a clear point about our senses, especially our sight. For example, she writes: “You watch these swaying yellow, green, and brown strands of algae half mesmerized; you sink into the microscope’s field forgetful, oblivious, as if it were all a dream of your deepest brain.” I feel that Dillard highlights the importance of our senses, as they allow us to recognize the diverse and different properties the earth provides. For the second story, which was about the descriptions of swans, Dillard specifically describes details of what she senses. For example she writes: “when they emerged they were flying suddenly very high, and it was like music changing key.” Here, Dillard incorporates two senses, which are hearing and seeing. Daniella, why do you think Dillard changes the subject after telling her story about her microscope by saying, “But oddly, this story is about swans.”?
Monday, June 7, 2010
Total Eclipse
Sumeet,
So this essay to me was completely confusing. I did not enjoy as I enjoyed the others. I believe it was to long for my taste. I think the theme and the hidden message in this essay is about how we don't fully appreciate things, and we kind of know about them but we simply just don't really care. We are fine the way we are and we don't need to improve or see more. Yet I found it odd how Dillard expresses fear towards the eclipse. I always thought that Dillard like the unknown and kind of nature miracles but through this essay she discuses the fear she has towards the eclipse and “it had been like dying, that sliding down the mountain pass,” (page 84). I mean she even starts off the essay with how terrified she was of the eclipse and foreshadows the rest of the essay. So my kind of question for you is first of all if you disagree with my point of view (which you probably will) and what you think about Dillard's scare of the unknown, darkness?
So this essay to me was completely confusing. I did not enjoy as I enjoyed the others. I believe it was to long for my taste. I think the theme and the hidden message in this essay is about how we don't fully appreciate things, and we kind of know about them but we simply just don't really care. We are fine the way we are and we don't need to improve or see more. Yet I found it odd how Dillard expresses fear towards the eclipse. I always thought that Dillard like the unknown and kind of nature miracles but through this essay she discuses the fear she has towards the eclipse and “it had been like dying, that sliding down the mountain pass,” (page 84). I mean she even starts off the essay with how terrified she was of the eclipse and foreshadows the rest of the essay. So my kind of question for you is first of all if you disagree with my point of view (which you probably will) and what you think about Dillard's scare of the unknown, darkness?
Sunday, June 6, 2010
On a Hill Far Away
Daniella,
As I read the essay “On a Hill Far Away”, I feel that the author’s point is just about the simplicity in life. Dillard keeps referring to this place on a hill top, where she meets a boy. When Dillard writes: “Until then I had not connected this land, these horses, and this little boy with the woman in the big house…”, I feel that she tries to transmit the fact that we have changed the way we are supposed to live. I don’t know if you understand me, but we humans have revolutionized life, and there are just few of us who are living the way the boy and his mother live. We should actually be learning to catch fish, and confront nature. I may once again be completely wrong, but I would like to know your perspective about Dillard’s point in this essay.
As I read the essay “On a Hill Far Away”, I feel that the author’s point is just about the simplicity in life. Dillard keeps referring to this place on a hill top, where she meets a boy. When Dillard writes: “Until then I had not connected this land, these horses, and this little boy with the woman in the big house…”, I feel that she tries to transmit the fact that we have changed the way we are supposed to live. I don’t know if you understand me, but we humans have revolutionized life, and there are just few of us who are living the way the boy and his mother live. We should actually be learning to catch fish, and confront nature. I may once again be completely wrong, but I would like to know your perspective about Dillard’s point in this essay.
Teaching a stone to talk
Summeet,
As I read Teaching a Stone to talk by Anne Dillards, I was hit by several questions about the theme of the essay. First of all, I found it a little confusing but as I got into it I understood that she was talking about the silence of nature and how we should appreciate it. When she says “ silence is not our heritage but our destiny; we live where we want to live” (p.69) I feel that she is confirming this. I also think that she is trying to emphasize to the reader that the silence encompasses a lot more than we imagine. When she says “ The silence is not actually suppression; instead, it is all there is.”(p.72) she is describing the fact that all things are silent for a purpose, for us to listen. I especially liked the part when she says she wants” to come back as a palo santo tree” (p. 76), to be a witness of the world. Once again I think that she chooses the palo santo tree because they are standing there, silent and they are a perfect example of a good listener. What did you think of the way she describes the silence?
As I read Teaching a Stone to talk by Anne Dillards, I was hit by several questions about the theme of the essay. First of all, I found it a little confusing but as I got into it I understood that she was talking about the silence of nature and how we should appreciate it. When she says “ silence is not our heritage but our destiny; we live where we want to live” (p.69) I feel that she is confirming this. I also think that she is trying to emphasize to the reader that the silence encompasses a lot more than we imagine. When she says “ The silence is not actually suppression; instead, it is all there is.”(p.72) she is describing the fact that all things are silent for a purpose, for us to listen. I especially liked the part when she says she wants” to come back as a palo santo tree” (p. 76), to be a witness of the world. Once again I think that she chooses the palo santo tree because they are standing there, silent and they are a perfect example of a good listener. What did you think of the way she describes the silence?
Thursday, June 3, 2010
The Deer at Providencia
Daniella,
As I read the essay “The Deer at Providencia”, I couldn’t help but disagree more with Annie Dillard, who towards the end mentioned a sarcastic remark which made me question her as the speaker. I feel that it is fine for her to not feel pity for the dear at the beginning of the essay, but towards the end, saying “Pobercito” and stating “it was a ridiculous thing to say” just was unnecessary. I, in a personal point of view, feel that all living things in the planet should be respected and valued, and Dillard opposes this in the essay. I, while reading the essay, actually felt sad and depressed about the deer dying. This is because Dillard uses such vivid imagery that it allows the reader to perceive each and every moment. For example, Dillard writes: “Its skin looked virtually hairless, in fact, and almost translucent, like a membrane. Its neck was no thicker than my wrist.;” Daniella, how do you feel about Dillard’s way of expressing her ignorance and unawareness?
As I read the essay “The Deer at Providencia”, I couldn’t help but disagree more with Annie Dillard, who towards the end mentioned a sarcastic remark which made me question her as the speaker. I feel that it is fine for her to not feel pity for the dear at the beginning of the essay, but towards the end, saying “Pobercito” and stating “it was a ridiculous thing to say” just was unnecessary. I, in a personal point of view, feel that all living things in the planet should be respected and valued, and Dillard opposes this in the essay. I, while reading the essay, actually felt sad and depressed about the deer dying. This is because Dillard uses such vivid imagery that it allows the reader to perceive each and every moment. For example, Dillard writes: “Its skin looked virtually hairless, in fact, and almost translucent, like a membrane. Its neck was no thicker than my wrist.;” Daniella, how do you feel about Dillard’s way of expressing her ignorance and unawareness?
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
In the Jungle
Daniella,
As I read the essay "In the Jungle" by Annie Dillard, many thoughts came to my head. In this essay, Dillard shows the importance of life, something which truly stood out to me, and made me think about how most human beings are stuck in their own little world. Most of us have not been “living” because we have not appreciated the wonders in our planet. This made me think of some questions such as: How do you feel Dillard expresses the meaning of life through the enriching imagery she incorporates? In what ways has Dillard brought the essay to life?
As I read the essay "In the Jungle" by Annie Dillard, many thoughts came to my head. In this essay, Dillard shows the importance of life, something which truly stood out to me, and made me think about how most human beings are stuck in their own little world. Most of us have not been “living” because we have not appreciated the wonders in our planet. This made me think of some questions such as: How do you feel Dillard expresses the meaning of life through the enriching imagery she incorporates? In what ways has Dillard brought the essay to life?
Monday, May 31, 2010
Living like Weasels
Sumeet,
As I read the essay "Living like Weasels" by Annie Dillard I questioned the possibiliteis of humans living their lives to satisfy their needs like a wild animal does (weasel) to survive; wild animals do every thing they do because of the need to survive, while humans on the other hand tend to make decisions based on motive or choices. What I mean by this is that we base our daily live decissions no only in our needs but our wants. As Dillard says throught the essay she always mentions how the wezeal does everything by instinct, how they are "obedient to their instinct" (page 11) and "the yank of separation, the careening splash-down into real life and the urgent current of instinct" (page 14). She emphasizes on how she wishes she could be more like the weasel basing everything on instinct and not on humans needs and choices. Do you think that we could live like the weasel like Dillard mentions? As in by instinct and not by choice?
-Daniella
As I read the essay "Living like Weasels" by Annie Dillard I questioned the possibiliteis of humans living their lives to satisfy their needs like a wild animal does (weasel) to survive; wild animals do every thing they do because of the need to survive, while humans on the other hand tend to make decisions based on motive or choices. What I mean by this is that we base our daily live decissions no only in our needs but our wants. As Dillard says throught the essay she always mentions how the wezeal does everything by instinct, how they are "obedient to their instinct" (page 11) and "the yank of separation, the careening splash-down into real life and the urgent current of instinct" (page 14). She emphasizes on how she wishes she could be more like the weasel basing everything on instinct and not on humans needs and choices. Do you think that we could live like the weasel like Dillard mentions? As in by instinct and not by choice?
-Daniella
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)