Sunday, June 6, 2010

On a Hill Far Away

Daniella,
As I read the essay “On a Hill Far Away”, I feel that the author’s point is just about the simplicity in life. Dillard keeps referring to this place on a hill top, where she meets a boy. When Dillard writes: “Until then I had not connected this land, these horses, and this little boy with the woman in the big house…”, I feel that she tries to transmit the fact that we have changed the way we are supposed to live. I don’t know if you understand me, but we humans have revolutionized life, and there are just few of us who are living the way the boy and his mother live. We should actually be learning to catch fish, and confront nature. I may once again be completely wrong, but I would like to know your perspective about Dillard’s point in this essay.

3 comments:

  1. Summet,
    I somewhat agree with you. The way of life back then was simple and filled with religion like Dillard mentions both the mom and the son ask Dillard "Do you know the lord as your personal savior?". I have noticed throught Dillards essays the there is a lot of faith put into them. I beleive that she puts religion into her essays because some people see faith and religion as the only way to live. Like in the essay the mom would drive 1 hour to go to church and back this shows determinatio0n of fatih. Moreover, I believe that the point of this essay is survival and simplicity of life but as well faith and beliefs. Saying that how do you feel about people with there religion these days? and does location mater since this is sucha a small city do you think in a place like NYC would be the same?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Daniella,
    I am glad we somewhat share the same idea in this essay. Answering your questions, I feel that the first question is very general, and can have many or different answers. For instance, today, I feel that the world is divided when religion is involved because there are people who follow their religion and others that don’t. I feel that many catholic people don’t follow their religion entirely, while Muslims follow their religion to an extreme. Answering your second question, I feel that location somewhat matters because of the amount of people that live in a specific place. As you say, in New York City it would be different because there are more people who are influenced by other’s beliefs, and therefore end up not following their religion. Now Daniella, you mentioned survival. How do you feel survival plays a role in the essay?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sumeet,
    I feel survival takes a role since they do talk about fishing, and the kid not being able to go to the creek due to safety. It shows that people take more precautions and have to learn what to do in a wild situation. I think this essay would have been 10 times better if it would have been a little longer and detailed. The way she describes her way of living makes it seem shes lives out in the country which you do need to know survival skills for. Once I went to my friends farm in Texas and the only food source were basically the animals. You also had to watch out for snakes and spiders so when I read this essay it kind of reminded me of that and how I hated it because I used to say "I hate working to feed myself." The point of all of this story was that survival plays a major role but I believe it only plays a huge role due to setting. If it wasn't for the "high grassy hill" (page 77) kind of setting, survival wouldn't have been such a huge role. I know Dillard likes to write about her life and things of her past but I was wondering if you saw a purpose to the essay. I mean the essay felt like a short children book in a way. I was wondering if you saw kind of a reason to tell the reader this story.

    ReplyDelete