Summeet,
As I read Teaching a Stone to talk by Anne Dillards, I was hit by several questions about the theme of the essay. First of all, I found it a little confusing but as I got into it I understood that she was talking about the silence of nature and how we should appreciate it. When she says “ silence is not our heritage but our destiny; we live where we want to live” (p.69) I feel that she is confirming this. I also think that she is trying to emphasize to the reader that the silence encompasses a lot more than we imagine. When she says “ The silence is not actually suppression; instead, it is all there is.”(p.72) she is describing the fact that all things are silent for a purpose, for us to listen. I especially liked the part when she says she wants” to come back as a palo santo tree” (p. 76), to be a witness of the world. Once again I think that she chooses the palo santo tree because they are standing there, silent and they are a perfect example of a good listener. What did you think of the way she describes the silence?
Fascinating ideas about silence. I will let Sumeet respond to your question. But I will pose two more. Are you okay with silence and how Dillard describes it? Do you aspire to obtain the silence she writes about?
ReplyDeleteDaniella,
ReplyDeleteAs I read “Teaching a Stone to talk”, I, like you, found that there were several approaches to understand the theme of the essay. Even though I may be wrong, I feel that the overall theme of the essay is how death is a part of nature, and how silence is the path to get to it. I feel that the way Annie Dillard describes the silence is through darkness, and the way nature and God surround and relate to it. For example when she writes: “The wilderness generation was at Sinai; it witnessed there the thick darkness where God was.” Here, I feel that reader gets an image related to death, where one can only encounter God when you die. Also, the quote you used before: “silence is not our heritage but our destiny”, I feel that Dillard here is relating silence with death, because we all know that at the end, we are going to die. Answering Mr. Pruzinsky, I am ok with silence because it is something we are all prepared for no matter what we do. The way Dillard describes it simply shows us how it will be when the time comes we face death. Daniella, how do you feel about death as a theme? Are you going to disagree with me again?
Sumeet,
ReplyDeleteYou are right about me disagreeing with your view. I really thought that the whole essay was more about life and us not paying attention to everything that God put there for us to look at, listen, enjoy. I even felt that Dillard wanted us to transport ourselves to the Galapagos and just observe the way the palo Alto trees there see it all. When she says, "And taking it all in are the trees" (p 73)
In response to Mr. Pruzinsky's questions, yes I do love the silence and I totally agree with the way she describes it. I was able to enjoy some of the silence on our jungle trip. There you could just close your eyes and enjoy the sounds that nature has to offer without the noices that contaminate the silence. I do aspire to obtain this silence and become a better listener of nature.
Daniella,
ReplyDeleteFinalizing this essay’s thoughts, I feel that you are right about this essay being about life, but I also feel the exact opposite, death. I feel the essay is an antithesis as a whole, which allows the reader to view both perspectives about life and death. I do agree with you with your answer to Mr. Pruzinsky’s question. I, like you, hope to obtain the silence Dillard writes about, and I feel I have felt it in many opportunities throughout my life, but only when I was surrounded by nature.