Daniella,
I feel that the essay “Lenses” has a theme that expresses the importance and significance of the human senses. I feel that the essay is oddly separated into two different stories, but deals with the same theme all throughout. For the first story, which was about the speaker’s microscope and the specific details it provides, I feel that Dillard makes a clear point about our senses, especially our sight. For example, she writes: “You watch these swaying yellow, green, and brown strands of algae half mesmerized; you sink into the microscope’s field forgetful, oblivious, as if it were all a dream of your deepest brain.” I feel that Dillard highlights the importance of our senses, as they allow us to recognize the diverse and different properties the earth provides. For the second story, which was about the descriptions of swans, Dillard specifically describes details of what she senses. For example she writes: “when they emerged they were flying suddenly very high, and it was like music changing key.” Here, Dillard incorporates two senses, which are hearing and seeing. Daniella, why do you think Dillard changes the subject after telling her story about her microscope by saying, “But oddly, this story is about swans.”?
Sumeet,
ReplyDeleteI kinda felt the second part of this essay was kind of corny. As she describes during Valentines Day she see's the whistling songs. I mean the whole idea of swans in valentines day really corny. Which is why I believe that the theme of this essay is more love then anything. I can see why you believe it is our senses but I don't believe Dillard would write about our senses. She usually has a deeper meaning to everything. Which is why I think there is a deeper meaning to this essay. Yet Dillard did confuses me as shes at first starts off talking about her childhood and the microscope she use to use and then out of nowhere she goes to this corny story about swans. Do you have any idea why she does this weird change of setting, atmosphere in the middle of the essay?
Daniella,
ReplyDeleteYou are right about the fact that Dillard has a deeper meaning to everything, but my reason to say that the theme is about human senses was because I noticed that being the main point. The essay is divided in two sections, and I actually don’t believe that the first part was about love, therefore supporting my argument that the overall theme of the essay is about our senses. Well, answering your question, which was actually quite similar to mine, I believe that Dillard decides to make a change in the essay to prove how two completely different stories can still have similar meanings. There is a change in setting and atmosphere as you mentioned, but I feel that her argument about our senses remains the same. I may be completely wrong, but that is what I believe. As I asked before in my first response, how do YOU feel about the sudden change in subjects Dillard incorporates?