Monday, May 31, 2010

Living like Weasels

Sumeet,
As I read the essay "Living like Weasels" by Annie Dillard I questioned the possibiliteis of humans living their lives to satisfy their needs like a wild animal does (weasel) to survive; wild animals do every thing they do because of the need to survive, while humans on the other hand tend to make decisions based on motive or choices. What I mean by this is that we base our daily live decissions no only in our needs but our wants. As Dillard says throught the essay she always mentions how the wezeal does everything by instinct, how they are "obedient to their instinct" (page 11) and "the yank of separation, the careening splash-down into real life and the urgent current of instinct" (page 14). She emphasizes on how she wishes she could be more like the weasel basing everything on instinct and not on humans needs and choices. Do you think that we could live like the weasel like Dillard mentions? As in by instinct and not by choice?
-Daniella

4 comments:

  1. Interesting question you pose to Sumeet. I wonder if you can define it a bit more for me. What does it mean to live by instinct? Is is always the violent and aggressive actions or reactions the weasel takes? And does living by choice mean being more passive? What is Dillard suggesting to us readers?

    As usual, I provide more questions than answers!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Daniella, I understand what you mean when you say that humans make decisions based on motive or choices. We also have to take into account the intelligence level of a weasel and compare it to that of us humans. There is a world of difference. Humans not only make choices based on their needs and desires, but also on what they consider right and wrong. Weasels on the other hand act only on instinct which is based only on their need to survive. I don’t think we humans could live like weasels and neither should we. Humans have the capacity to make choices and that’s what makes us different and that is something to embrace. Dillard expresses her approval “to grasp your one necessity” (page 16) just like a weasel does with its prey, but in the real human world I feel there are multiple necessities and you have to use more than just your instinct to grasp them. So I feel it is not only impossible but rather irrational to live like a weasel.
    -Sumeet

    ReplyDelete
  3. Answer to English teacher:
    What I meant by living by instinct is similar to how Dillard describes it, that the weasel as a wild animal kills its prey because it needs to eat to survive as Dillard puts it "a weasel lives as hes meant to, yielding at every moment to the perfect freedom of single necessity." (page 16). I also believe that the wild weasel does act aggressively and violently because he doesn't have the ability to think, to make a choice about it. His instinct is to bite his prey and not let go. I think that Dillard is suggesting that it would be possible for humans to hold on to their own necessity's and by choice not let them go.

    Now Sumeet:
    I disagree with you. I believe that we are somewhat equal to the weasel. Just because the weasel doesn't talk or walk like us it doesn't mean it doesn't have a brain and thoughts of its own. It still lives by a routine not the same as humans but this doesn't make the weasel less intelligent. I believe the fact that the weasel stalks its preys and grabs them by the neck shows more then just instinct, not a choice but the ability to know where to bite its prey. Another thing that caught my attention in the essay was Dillard's ability to describe the setting in such a vivid way that I felt like I was there. The use of figurative language made it possible for the reader to know the calm location where she met the weasel. I especially liked the part where she says "the sun had just set. I was relaxed on the tree trunk, ensconced in the lap of lichens," (page 13). I really enjoyed the setting yet I can't stop wondering whether the setting has a significant purpose to the essay. What I mean is if Dillard would have chosen another setting for the weasel would it have made a difference to the reader or the essay?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Daniella, I agree that the setting was completely captivating. Dillard’s descriptions are thorough and detailed. She invites the reader into her neighborhood and practically becomes a tour guide. I felt and visualized every image she expressed and wanted to be there with her when she encountered the weasel. I feel the setting has an important role in the essay. The calmness and beauty felt on that summer day is compensated by the fierce and wild nature of the weasel she encounters. The physical differences between the setting and its habitant, the weasel, captured my interest immediately. These contrasts are what make this reading enjoyable and pleasant. I am convinced that if Dillard had chosen another setting, this essay would not have been as enjoyable. Besides it seems like she actually experienced this event so her descriptions are real and not just imagined. Her real life encounter with the weasel in her neighborhood is what she intended to convey and she does so effectively.
    -Sumeet

    ReplyDelete