Thursday, June 3, 2010

The Deer at Providencia

Daniella,
As I read the essay “The Deer at Providencia”, I couldn’t help but disagree more with Annie Dillard, who towards the end mentioned a sarcastic remark which made me question her as the speaker. I feel that it is fine for her to not feel pity for the dear at the beginning of the essay, but towards the end, saying “Pobercito” and stating “it was a ridiculous thing to say” just was unnecessary. I, in a personal point of view, feel that all living things in the planet should be respected and valued, and Dillard opposes this in the essay. I, while reading the essay, actually felt sad and depressed about the deer dying. This is because Dillard uses such vivid imagery that it allows the reader to perceive each and every moment. For example, Dillard writes: “Its skin looked virtually hairless, in fact, and almost translucent, like a membrane. Its neck was no thicker than my wrist.;” Daniella, how do you feel about Dillard’s way of expressing her ignorance and unawareness?

3 comments:

  1. Sumeet,
    I disagree with you. I do not believe that Dillard doesn't feel bad for the deer. Of course she feels bad about the deer but her way of dealing with it is how all of us should deal with things like these. What I mean by this is that sure we can feel sorry but we also need to learn to live with these things. These things happen everyday and we need to know how to deal with pity. I admire Dillard for this essay because it is so real. It is all about the pain and how us humans relate to animals once again. In this essay with the imagery you mentioned Dillard compares the suffering of the deer with the suffering of the guy (Alan). To me this essay had a depressing mood at first yet by the end when Dillard says that pain will always be in our life and we can't fight that. We should just learn how to live with it. The last part of the essay inspired me. I truly believe that Dillard is a carrying and real person not ignorant nor unaware. We all have a heart Sumeet we all feel bad but sometimes we should learn to live with that pain the way we live with happiness, anger, etc. The way we live and deal with these emotions is another natural daily part of life. Sumeet kind of changing the topic a little did you see any similarities or differences in the way both the deer and the guy suffer?
    (sorry I didn't quote a lot this time left my book at school)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Daniella,
    Well I can see you are disagreeing with me a lot, and that is why, before I change topics, I would like to defend myself. I understand when you say that we have to learn how to deal with pity, but the way Dillard approaches it is not correct. I mean, saying “poor little thing” and then saying “it was a ridiculous thing to say” is not acceptable for me. It actually made me feel anger and rage, and that is why I am defending my argument so much. Anyways, back to your new question, I feel that there are similarities in the way Alan McDonald and the deer suffer. For instance, in both cases, they “just lie there and weep” and later end up dying. I feel that Dillard purposely does this to show how life and death is always going to be a part of nature no matter whom or what we are. We are all living things, and we all will all end up experiencing the same thing end one way or another.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sumeet,
    I understand that it might seem odd for Dillard to write "it was a ridiculous thing to say" but again she is right. Even though it is sad that the deer is suffering we have to learn to deal with it with everything else in life. Sure feel bad for it but move on. Its Dillard's way of interpreting that we must learn how to live with pity that I truly admire about her. She says those things so we can live with the fact that the world isn't perfect and things will suffer and die and we must try to learn and live with those types of things. Sumeet even you somewhat agree with this argument when you say "life and death is always going to be a part of nature no matter" that's exactly Dillard's point. If its going to happen anyways learn to live with it, respect it. It is life. The theme of pain and life are shown all around the essay as we have been discussing. And what I thought was interesting is the way Dillard describes the deer's pain the same as the guy's pain how they both try to end their pain the deer by trying to set himself free and the man trying to kill himself. I really like how Dillard talks about both scenes since they are both kind of the same.

    ReplyDelete